Archive for Wahid Abdel Meguid

The ballot and the street

“The President and the Brotherhood take credit for the most significant achievement the opposition made this year,” says Tamer al-Mihy, member of the political bureau of the Social Democratic Party. “That they started to unite and work together,” he reckons.

Mihy is speaking about the National Salvation Front, an umbrella group of various political groups and personalities that formed in November to oppose Islamist hegemony over the political scene. The front offered a form of political representation to a growing anti-Islamist street movement.

Scores had been gathering outside the presidential palace and in Tahrir Square to protest President Mohamed Morsy’s controversial power grab through a constitutional declaration, parts of which he later rescinded under popular pressure.

So far, the front has managed to remain relatively united throughout the fast-moving political developments of November and December.

The future, however, poses two challenges to this nascent political opposition.

The first is how to contest a robust Islamist movement, which has on its side repeated electoral victories. The second is how to represent a street movement that often resists political representation.

Eye on the ballot

Opposition parties and figures who rose to prominence after the revolution have learned the hard way that they cannot make political gains without uniting against more organized Islamist powers, especially those with decades-long organizational experience.

In the run-up to last year’s parliamentary elections, 14 liberal and leftist parties formed an electoral alliance, The Egyptian Bloc. However, parties dropped out of the alliance one by one due to disagreements over seat distribution; come election day, the alliance was comprised of only three parties. The bloc also had to compete for non-Islamist votes with another liberal electoral alliance, the Revolution Continues.

Islamist groups, spearheaded by the Muslim Brotherhood and the Salafi Nour Party, meanwhile, took 70 percent of seats in parliament.

In the presidential elections, the same non-Islamist players remained divided, and the revolutionary vote was split. Nasserist leader Hamdeen Sabbahi, Muslim Brotherhood defector Abdel Moneim Abouel Fotouh and leftist human rights lawyer Khaled Ali — all considered candidates of the revolution — ran separately. None of them made it to the runoffs.

The results of this month’s constitutional referendum suggest the united opposition is much more competetive. The 63.8 percent with which the Islamist-friendly constitution was approved reflects a weakening of Islamists’ electoral prowess, with less than 33 percent of eligible voters showing up to the polls.

With new parliamentary elections expected to be held within the next two months, the electoral field will become once again a proving ground for the opposition.

Hassan Abu Taleb, a political expert at Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies, says whether the front remains united will depend on whether its member parties can put aside their own political interests and continue to fight together against the domination of the Islamist current.

There is more demand for unity now than in past elections, says Mihy, and steeper political consequences for parties that decide to run independently. Thus, there is a greater chance, he says, that the opposition will remain unified.

“We all agree on the general goals of restraining a fascist authority and changing the constitution,” he says. “Now there’s popular pressure that will make it difficult for a party to announce it is leaving the ranks of the united opposition. It would be political suicide.”

Mihy says that to improve its ability to mobilize voters, the front aims to build a strong, institutionalized mechanism and enhance communication between Cairo and the governorates. The referendum showcased the opposition’s significant weakness outside major urban centers.

He adds that over the last few months, opposition party bases have worked together in the governorates as teams, which they will be resistant to dismantle.

Amid speculation over what form future cooperation between front members will take, Wahid Abdel Meguid, a member of the front’s political bureau, tells Egypt Independent that the front is considering running its members on one list in the upcoming elections.

Abu Taleb says the front’s major task now is to work toward securing at least half the seats in the parliament and then to use those gains to bring down the constitution through legislative means.

“If they run on one list, [opposition parties] will see a strong victory and change the current political landscape, which is dominated by the Brotherhood and the Salafis,” he says.

Abdel Meguid denies rumors that the front will start a new party; however, he says some parties in the front are planning to merge.

Eye on the street

While the front says the upcoming elections are its priority, it also vows to continue working as a revolutionary force in the street.

Leading members of the front have stressed that while it will participate in electoral politics, the front refuses to accept the status quo the ruling Muslim Brotherhood has forced on the country.

“We represent a revolutionary opposition and also an institutional opposition that works through the legitimate mechanisms of elections, and when the rights of the people are being violated, we stand with them in the street through protests and sit-ins, which are additional tools of opposition,” says Abdel Meguid.

Many in the leadership value the street movement as the compass of the opposition.

“The most important development in the opposition is that it has learned that it’s not about figures or stars. What determines their success is the amount of work they do in the street,” says Abu Taleb. “Without work on the street, the figures remain leaders without soldiers, and everyone loses.”

Meanwhile, Akram Ismail, a member of the Popular Socialist Alliance who credits the opposition’s organizational development with an increasing ability to mobilize on a street level, is concerned with the movement’s potential.

“The opposition’s political power is capable of creating pressure on the rule of the Brotherhood, but not replacing it,” he says. “They can disrupt a lot of things, but they cannot take initiative.”

“The opposition is not one party with one agenda; it’s a wide alliance that spans from the liberal right to the socialist left,” he says, which can pose a structural impediment to its political ascendancy.

But for him, and at least for now, the opposition’s agenda is not to rule but to pressure the ruling Brotherhood to make compromises that lead to a more democratic state and hinder “their attempt to rebuild dictatorial rule.”

This piece appears in Egypt Independent's weekly print edition.

Tags: , , ,

Wahid Abdel Meguid, the spokesperson for the Constituent Assembly, warned against gridlock in drafting Egypt's new constitution and said secular members of the assembly might withdraw because they have been prevented from speaking and proposing different wording for crucial provisions in the final document.

On a phone call with “The People Want,” a program on the satellite channel Tahrir, Abdel Meguid said the “withdrawal of civil forces has become widely proposed after conflicts that have taken place, which could lead to an impasse if they continue.” He was referring to arbitrary moderation practices in sessions by Hossam al-Gheriany, the head of the assembly. 

Abdel Meguid cited one instance during discussions of the chapter concerning the portions defining the basic principles of the state on Monday.

During a meeting while voting on the section, former presidential candidate Amr Moussa rejected the first article, on which the majority had voted. He said that there was a mistake in referring to Asian aspects of Egyptian identity, arguing that it was not like the African, Arab or Islamic dimensions of Egyptian identity.

Gheriany rejected Moussa’s comment, saying the article had been voted on and that none of the assembly wanted to discuss it. Moussa responded by saying that this was suppression of alternative points of view. Gheriany told Moussa that he had expressed his opinion and called on him to respect the majority’s choice.

Moussa then said, “If we stopped the discussion, then we would not discuss any other article until the constitution is drafted.”

Abdel Galil Mostafa, another member, tried to comment, when Gheriany asked him to sit down and refused to let him speak, prompting a retort from Mostafa.

“I don’t accept this suppression,” he said. “We objected [to] Mubarak during the hardest circumstances.”

Essam al-Erian of the Muslim Brotherhood responded, “It’s us who objected and were imprisoned. You weren’t imprisoned even once,” before left the meeting. 

Tags: , , , , , ,

 

Leaders of political parties with representatives in the Constituent Assembly will convene on Tuesday to discuss achieving consensus between Islamist and liberal groups on controversial constitutional articles, said assembly member and Nour Party leader Younis Makhyoun.

Speaking to the London-based Al-Hayat newspaper, Makhyoun played down political disagreements, evidenced by Islamists’ calls for demonstrations Friday to demand Sharia as the country’s main source of legislation. “Those are merely differences in points of views which we seek to overcome with consensus,” he said.

He added that assembly members have agreed on all constitutional articles except for ten that are related to freedoms, women's rights and presidential powers.

The assembly's committees will begin Tuesday to review the first constitutional draft, issued last week, Makhyoun said. He added that the assembly will, then, issue a complete draft during the first week of November that will be subject to public debate followed by a referendum in mid-November. He said the constitution will, therefore, be ready for referendum before December.

Muslim Brotherhood official and assembly member Farid Ismail told the newspaper that different political groups agree more than disagree, and said that the new constitution would meet the aspirations of all Egyptians.

Assembly member Wahid Abdel Meguid said, without specifying, that some political parties "do not distinguish between a constitution and a partisan platform and are not aware that constitutions are drafted by consensus rather than according to the will of the majority."

Abdel Meguid described Islamist threats to protest to push for certain articles as "an unprecedented phenomenon," adding that constitutions should represent all of the country’s social sectors.

Tags: , , ,

Thursday’s press shows conflicting reports about the future of journalists convicted of libel and defamation in the Muslim Brotherhood-led political order.

The mouthpiece newspaper of the nation’s de facto rulers, Freedom and Justice, says that the new constitution is set to prohibit jail sentences for journalists. The paper quotes Wahid Abdel Meguid, the official spokesperson of the Constituent Assembly, as saying that the assembly has dropped an initial suggestion to include an article stipulating that journalists would be jailed if they were convicted of libelous or defamatory reporting, fomenting hate, or damaging people’s sexual lives.

The constitution’s architects adopted a new article stating clearly that journalists cannot be jailed for any press crime, according to Abdel Meguid, as quoted in the Muslim Brotherhood’s daily. All suggested clauses are to be discussed in the assembly’s general committee before they are set for public referendum. Hence, further changes could be incorporated.

Meanwhile, the privately owned Al-Shorouk daily quotes President Mohamed Morsy’s justice minister as ruling out the possibility that jail sentences would no longer apply to press crimes. Ahmed Mekky told the paper: “I dreamt of abolishing jail sentences for journalists and limiting [punishment] to fines and moral sanctions imposed by the syndicate, which include barring journalists from the practice and dismissing them from the syndicate. However, these sanctions are not enough to reform the press.” According to Al-Shorouk, Mekky is immersed in hammering out the details of a new press law that “would prevent the press from lying.”

“It is too early to realize the dream of prohibiting jail sentences for press crimes. The press lies and is governed by bad faith and whims,” added Mekky in the report. 

The privately owned Al-Watan newspaper leads with a headline reading that the Brotherhood’s Guidance Bureau held “a secret meeting” on Tuesday to come up with a list of candidates for the president to appoint to the Shura Council. By law, the president has the right to appoint one-third of the members of the Parliament’s upper house. At the same meeting, the Brothers came up with another list of people for Morsy to hire as members of the National Council for Human Rights.

As benign as it may sound, this piece of news attributed to anonymous sources hits a sensitive nerve with many readers who doubt Morsy’s independence from the Brotherhood. While Morsy’s presidential team always claims that his decisions are made independently from his religio-political organization, such news refutes the purported autonomy of Egypt’s first democratically elected president.

Meanwhile, the state-owned press is concerned with singing the praises of Morsy’s visit to China. Both Al-Ahram and Al-Akhbar lead with headlines claiming that Morsy succeeded in convincing the Chinese to invest US$6 billion in Egypt. Like in the old days of Hosni Mubarak, Al-Ahram’s front page leads with a medium-size photo of Morsy holding talks with the Chinese prime minister.

The paper goes on to quote Hassan Malek, a businessman and a presidential adviser, as saying that Morsy’s delegation succeeded in “signing preliminary agreements between the two countries worth $5.8 billion.” The paper does not give any further details on the timetable for injecting this money or these investments, which leaves the reader with the impression that the figures are used for sheer propaganda purposes.

On another front, Thursday’s papers highlight the ongoing debate over the new government-sponsored emergency bill. The justice minister recently announced that he is drafting a new emergency law to replace the notorious one used frequently during the Mubarak regime. The announcement has elicited an uncomfortable stir among human rights activists and liberals.

Many suspect that Morsy is seeking to consolidate power by reactivating a new version of the exceptional law. Al-Akhbar newspaper quotes Mohamed Mahsoub Abdel Meguid, parliamentary affairs minister, as saying that the old law would be amended so that human rights, liberties and the judiciary would be respected even if a state of emergency were declared and the new emergency law were enforced. He added that the law might not be enforced nationwide but in certain areas according to need. Yet, these assurances have failed to convince liberal politicians like Amr Hamzawy.

The former MP has a column in today’s Al-Watan newspaper raising suspicion over the timing of bringing up this issue and expressing his opposition to the content of the government-suggested bill. Hamzawy contends that there is no need to discuss this new legislation now that there is no Parliament.

"It is hard to understand why President Morsy and his government insists on issuing a new emergency law before the constitution is finished and before [a new] Parliament is elected," wonders Hamzawy. Meanwhile, Hamzawy dismisses the bill for its inclusion of clauses that give the president "sweeping and dangerous powers" and "overturn a lot of rights and liberties."

Hamzawy concludes: "The bill brings back exceptional courts under the name of emergency and military tribunals. This is a dangerous infringement on values of democracy and the rule of law."

Egypt’s papers:

Al-Ahram: Daily, state-run, largest distribution in Egypt

Al-Akhbar: Daily, state-run, second to Al-Ahram in institutional size

Al-Gomhurriya: Daily, state-run

Rose al-Youssef: Daily, state-run

Al-Dostour: Daily, privately owned

Al-Shorouk: Daily, privately owned

Al-Watan: Daily, privately owned

Al-Wafd: Daily, published by the liberal Wafd Party

Youm7: Daily, privately owned

Al-Tahrir: Daily, privately owned

Freedom and Justice: Daily, published by the Muslim Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice Party

Sawt al-Umma: Weekly, privately owned

Al-Arabi: Weekly, published by the Nasserist Party

Al-Nour: Official paper of the Salafi Nour Party

Tags: , , , , ,

The Constituent Assembly needs more time to finalize the new constitution and to reach a consensus over its articles, said assembly spokesperson Wahid Abdel Meguid on Monday.

"After extensive discussions over the ideas suggested by assembly members for the past month and a half, it was determined that we need three more months to finalize the draft before it can be put to a referendum," Abdel Meguid told state-run news agency MENA.

He said that the assembly has still not reached a consensus on the final wording of Article 2, which defines the application of Sharia law. Abdel Meguid predicted that that the controversy over the article will intensify before the matter is finally resolved.

The Constituent Assembly plenary session was postponed to Tuesday because there were no finalized articles to be discussed.

Gamal Gabriel, a member of the drafting committee, told Al-Masry Al-Youm on Monday that the committee has completed writing five new articles in the constitutional chapter on rights and freedoms. Ten articles in this chapter have now been completed.

The five completed articles are related to the freedom of religion, opinion and thought, as well as the freedom of press and media, Gabriel said.

The judiciary committee, a subset of the systems of governance committee, has completed work on proposed articles related to the judicial branch of the government and will present them for discussion before sending the proposals to the drafting committee.

Members of the systems of governance committee fought on Monday while discussing the role of the military in the new constitution, a topic of ongoing debate for the assembly.

Mamdouh Shahin, a member of both the Constituent Assembly and the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, demanded that an article defining the role and responsibility of the military judiciary be added to chapter on the judiciary. Several committee members rejected the proposal on the grounds that the anything pertaining to the military judiciary should be written in the chapter of the armed forces.

Shahin then withdrew from the meeting in protest.

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm and MENA

Tags: , , ,

The Constituent Assembly tasked with writing Egypt's new constitution finished drafting its first article on Wednesday, which now states: “The Arab Republic of Egypt is a democratic, consultative, constitutional and modern state based on the separation of powers and the principle of citizenship.”

The article adds that, “Egypt is part of the Arab and Islamic nation, bound to the African continent with strong ties.”

Assembly member Meguid Shebeita said the word “consultative,” which is derived from the Arabic word Shoura, means “the participation of all authorities in the political and constitutional operations, so that no individual force can monopolize power in the state.”

The president is head of the armed forces and has the right to appoint the defense minister, and the military’s budget will remain private, only to be reviewed by Parliament in closed sessions, the assembly members agreed. Finally, they agreed that the president will be able to declare war only with the approval of the armed forces and Parliament.

On Wednesday evening the assembly also finished drafting a new article pertaining to the independence of Al-Azhar, said assembly member Huda Ghania. According to the article, Al-Azhar would become the nation’s Islamic authority and would independently of the government oversee its own budget and the appointment of its grand imam.

The committee also discussed amending Article 60 of the 1971 Constitution that stipulates that “maintaining national unity and keeping the secrets of the state is a duty for every citizen,” said Wahid Abdel Meguid, a member of the assembly’s rights, freedom and public duties committee.

Assembly members agreed that “state secrets” was an ambiguous term, said Abdel Meguid, and they would prefer to substitute the phrase “national security.”

A new article was also proposed that would guarantee the freedom of information and stipulate legal action against those found guilty of hiding or destroying information, except as pertains to military security or private life.

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , , , ,

Constituent Assembly spokesperson Wahid Abdel Meguid predicted Tuesday that Egypt’s new constitution would be drafted within three months.

Abdel Meguid said in a statement that a meeting of the assembly’s executive board considered reports from the different committees on their progress drafting constitutional articles.

The committee tasked with the wording of the constitution as a whole will be formed during the assembly’s meeting on Wednesday, he said.

The committee that deals with the basic components of the state has finished drafting the first article, which would state: “The Arab Republic of Egypt is democratic, consultative, constitutional, and modernized; based on separation of powers and principal of citizenship, it is part of the Arabic and Islamic nation and tied to the African continent.”

Yasser Borhamy, a member of the assembly and leader of the Salafi Dawah, told Al-Masry Al-Youm that “there was consensus among the committee’s members over the statement ‘Egypt is part of the Arabic and Islamic nation.’”

The use of the word “consultative” (shoureya) was suggested by a Salafi Dawah member and agreed upon by the committee’s members as an explanation for the word “democratic” in Arabic, he added.

“It is not mentioned in the first article that Egypt is an Islamic state because this is in the second article, and there is no need for repetition,” Borhamy explained, adding that, “We are against a theocratic state but insist that the second article state that Sharia, not its principles, is the main source of legislation to separate the state from radical secularism.”

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , ,

After four days of discussions, the mediation committee that was formed to end the impasse over the Constituent Assembly's current makeup agreed that the assembly should be formed from outside Parliament.

Committee member Wahid Abdel Meguid said 40 percent of the assembly would come from political parties, 15 percent from the judiciary and law professors, 10 percent youth, another 10 percent women, nine percent from professional syndicates, four percent from Al-Azhar, four percent from the Coptic Church, two percent from trade unions, a member of the armed forces, and a member of the police.

Abdel Meguid also said that political party representatives attended the meetings, most notably the Freedom and Justice Party, the Nour Party, the Egyptian Democratic Party and the Free Egyptians Party.

Tarek al-Sahry of the Nour Party said the liberals in the meetings objected to the presence of Islamists in the Constituent Assembly. “There are attempts to ban the Islamists from drafting the constitution,” he said, adding that the party ought to put down red lines when it comes to writing the constitution, namely that the Islamic Sharia is the main source of legislation, a mixed political system and separation of powers.

Yasser Borhamy of the same party said the party does not mind selecting the assembly members from outside Parliament, provided that all political parties are proportionately represented in it.

“The people chose the Islamists for Parliament,” he said. “Therefore, they should form 70 percent of the assembly.”

Adel Afify of the Asala Party called on the military council to announce the criteria for the formation of the assembly in a Constitutional Declaration to protect it from challenges and end the crisis over it.

Ahmed Abdel Rahman of the Freedom and Justice Party said the party is keen on a consensus among all political forces over the assembly so that it truly represents all segments of society. However, he rejected the idea of another Constitutional Declaration. 

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , ,

The general coordinator of the Freedom and Justice Party-led Democratic Alliance, Wahid Abdel Meguid, said a meeting of the committee mediating between the FJP and the Free Egyptians and Social Democratic parties to revolve the stalemate over the formation of the constituent assembly had yielded no results on Sunday.

The meeting was attended by Mohamed al-Beltagy, representing the FJP, Ahmed Saeed, head of the Free Egyptians Party, and Ziad Bahaa el-Din, head of the parliamentary bloc for the Social Democratic Party, Abdel Maguid told Al-Masry Al-Youm.

The head of the Wasat party’s parliamentary bloc mediated the meeting.

The Muslim Brotherhood would voluntarily replace some assembly members with alternates from the parties that feel underrepresented, Beltagy said.

The FJP refused to say reveal many members the party would withdraw before the proposition was accepted.  

Saeed and Bahaa el-Din, however, asked that the constituent assembly be dissolved and completely re-formed, Beltagy reported.

FJP MP Mostafa Ahmed told Al-Masry Al-Youm that the party is making contacts with other parties and withdrawn members regarding possible substitutions.

Deputy of the Shura Council and member of the constituent assembly Tarek al-Suhari said the stalemate is about to end as some withdrawn members have backtracked and will take part in Wednesday's meeting.

Translated from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , , , , ,

People’s Assembly Speaker Saad al-Katatny has been elected chairman of the assembly that will draft the country’s new constitution, assembly member Mohamed Omara said Wednesday.

State-run news agency MENA quoted Omara as saying that Katatny won 71 valid votes at the end of the vote count, noting that fellow member Moataz Bellah Abdel Fattah, a journalist, had decided not to vote.

Before the vote was conducted, panel members and MPs Wahid Abdel Meguid and Essam Sultan withdrew their panel memberships. They said they preferred to first form a committee to discuss the assembly’s activities before electing its chairman.

The Islamist-dominated constituent assembly held its first meeting Wednesday morning, attended by 74 out of 100 members.

State-run newspaper Al-Ahram said liberal members were absent from the meeting, while the majority of members from the Muslim Brotherhood’s Freedom and Justice Party were present.

General Mamdouh Shahin, an member of the ruling Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, and Emad Hussein, president of the Police Academy, as well as other public figures attended.

On Saturday, a number of secular political parties and liberal figures announced a boycott of the constitutional panel, arguing that it failed to represent various social sectors.

Counselors from the Supreme Constitutional Court on Wednesday apologized for not participating in the assembly. They said in a statement obtained by Al-Masry Al-Youm that the decision came after court discussions late Tuesday.

The court had nominated its vice president, Awad Saleh, for the assembly, but Saleh withdrew his membership, citing suspicion about the validity of the assembly’s elections procedures.

Tags: , , ,