Archive for energy subsidies

Electricity prices have not changed since 2008, the electricity and energy minister said Sunday.

Electricity and Energy Minister Mahmoud Saad Mahmoud Balbaa denied local newspaper reports that electricity prices have recently gone up, according to state TV. Instead, he said, “The increase that citizens find is a result of a change in consumption patterns over the past few months.”

The current government has expressed a desire to review existing energy subsidies, which totaled over LE111 billion last year.

“The [government-run] electricity sector spends about LE12.5 billion annually to provide houses with subsidized electricity,” Balbaa added. That figure does not include electricity provided to non-residential properties.

This summer, the country witnessed frequent power outages due to high power consumption from air conditioning use. The Cabinet has promised to resolve the energy issue soon.

Tags: , , , , ,

The Cabinet submitted an action plan to President Mohamed Morsy in a meeting Tuesday that, according to Prime Minister Hesham Qandil, emphasizes the objectives of the revolution — focusing on human development, economic reform and social justice.

The plan aims to achieve high sustainable growth rates through encouraging investments, reducing subsidies, adopting progressive taxation, and developing a comprehensive economic reform plan to address the flaws of the general budget, Qandil said.
 
The Cabinet issued a statement Tuesday stressing that the plan was developed by a number of experts and specialists in different fields over three months. It added that the Cabinet faced many obstacles, including widespread financial and administrative corruption and the absence of social justice. The statement pointed out that low-income people benefit from only 10 percent of energy subsidies, equal to LE117 billion.
 
At the end of June, the statement said, the unemployment rate was 13 percent, 25 percent of the population was living below the poverty line, and the budget deficit was LE168 billion.
 
The Cabinet's plan is divided into three parts: a short-term plan from 2012 to 2014, a medium-term plan from 2012 to 2017, and a long-term plan from 2017 to 2022, the statement added.
 
The plan aims to achieve economic growth at an average of seven percent per year until 2022, in addition to providing no less than 800,000 job opportunities before the end of the current fiscal year and increasing local and foreign investments to LE167 billion.
 
The statement said that the new plan aims to enable lower-income people to benefit from subsidies through reforming the bread and butane gas distribution system, increasing gas prices for energy-intensive industries, and distributing gasoline and diesel fuel through smart cards.
 
The Cabinet's plan includes a development project for Sinai worth LE1 billion. Funding for this project would be included in the budget for fiscal year 2012/2013, the statement said, adding that the Cabinet is aiming for the resettlement of nearly 1.5 million citizens in Sinai.
 
The plan also calls for upgrading health care programs, increasing allocations to the health sector and the improvement of health services.
 
The statement said that in order to ensure that the plan's objectives are met, a stable political climate should be provided through commitment to democracy, enforcement of the law, and protection of human rights, freedom of opinion, and equality.
 
Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm
Tags: , , , , , ,

A number of political groups staged a march Monday evening from the Egyptian Stock Exchange building in downtown Cairo to the Cabinet building to voice their opposition to the US$4.2 million loan from the International Monetary Fund.

Participants included members of the Karama Party, the Strong Egypt Party, the Socialist Popular Alliance Party, Kefaya, and others.

Former presidential candidate and rights activist Khaled Ali said the march aims to make citizens aware of the negative consequences of the loan, including raising the foreign debt by 50 percent and increasing allocations in the state budget to pay off the loan, which would affect subsidies, services and prices.

He added that the participants in the march reject the loan without community dialogue and an alternative economic plan to provide the necessary financial resources.

Ali warned of the lack of transparency regarding the IMF’s conditions and that the government would repay the loan from citizens’ pockets, noting that it would raise gas, water and electricity prices.

Participants in the march also demand that Prime Minister Hesham Qandil rationalize government spending as an alternative to foreign borrowing, lift energy subsidies to factories, and levy taxes on capital gains in the stock market to bridge the deficit.

Human rights organizations, political movements and trade unions had on Monday asked the prime minister to freeze loan negotiations with the IMF.

The Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, the Egyptian Center for Economic and Social Rights, the Popular Current and the Egyptian Federation of Independent Trade Unions said the negotiations are not transparent, nor is the government’s economic reform program.

They also said holding negotiations and making agreements without a parliament in place, while President Mohamed Morsy has legislative authority, violates the democratic principles of separation of powers and constitutional supervision of executive decisions.

They added that the government did not consult all civilian groups and political forces about the loan, which makes any feedback it received not representative of the whole Egyptian society.

The IMF had demanded total social consensus over the loan, especially as the austerity measures associated with it, such as the reduction of subsidies, could threaten the basic economic and social rights of the Egyptian people.

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , , ,

The government has taken a first step to getting expensive energy subsidies under control, a key component of an economic reform program the cash-strapped government is presenting to the IMF to obtain a loan.

The Cabinet received on Thursday the preliminary results of a pilot program to use ration cards to distribute cooking gas to the needy instead of selling it on demand, Petroleum Minister Osama Kamal said.

The government spent LE96 billion, or 20 percent of all expenditure, on subsidizing petroleum products, including cooking gas, in the financial year that ended on 30 June.

A reduction in the government's subsidy bill is likely to be a key component in any agreement with the International Monetary Fund. The government resumed negotiations with the IMF on a US$4.8 billion loan on Wednesday.

Under the current system, a canister of butane cooking gas, or "butagas," sells for around LE5, while it costs almost LE70 to produce.

Under the Petroleum Ministry's pilot program, which began on 1 October, the government sells the lower-cost canisters only to families carrying government ration cards or to people otherwise determined to be in need.

"Four governorates have begun the pioneering experiment to monitor and control butagas distribution by way of ration cards," Kamal told a news conference.

One of the governorates, or provinces, is Giza, which includes nearly half the population of greater Cairo.

The governor of Sohag Governorate, also part of the program, told the conference that the distribution plan had been 85 percent successful.

"We are reviewing the system for subsidizing petroleum products to save LE45 billion in the current fiscal year," Kamal said.

The government, which also subsidizes petrol, diesel and fuel oil, has been moving carefully to sell austerity measures to a public whose economic expectations have risen since last year's popular revolt.

"Everyone is agreed on the need to eliminate subsidies on 95 octane gasoline. Likewise, there is agreement on streamlining subsidies on butagas so that canisters reach those who need them," Kamal said.

Government officials say they are still studying how to reduce the cost of the lower-octane grades of petrol more widely consumed by the poor.

The IMF has asked Egypt to draw up an economic reform program to rein in a budget deficit that has mushroomed to 11 percent of gross domestic product since last year's uprising.

Tags: , , , ,

The delay in implementing energy subsidy cuts is costing the state LE10 billion every three months, claimed Petroleum Minister Osama Kamal on Monday.

These additional costs are on top of provisions in this year’s budget to boost the petroleum sector with an estimated LE70 billion.

While LE17.5 billion per quarter is typically set aside for energy subsidies, the state spent LE28 billion on these subsidies in the first quarter of this fiscal year alone, Kamal said.

The minister added that the subsidies would probably cost the state about the same for the second quarter without restructuring the subsidy system.

The budget for this fiscal year had been drafted assuming that energy subsidies would be restructured starting in early July, but that has not yet happened, partly due to the fact that governmental studies on the subsidies have not yet been finished, Kamal said.

Kamal told Al-Masry Al-Youm that studies are still ongoing into the quotas allocated to vehicle owners who benefit from petrol and diesel cards.

He stated that the government is working to finish the study before the end of 2012, and would present the conclusions to the public before applying them.

Kamal pointed out that a reported plan giving petrol cards to owners of cars with engines smaller than 1,600 cc was still only in a proposal phase and needed furthery study by officials. Decisions in that matter would be made to the benefit of the majority of users, he said.

Each car is scheduled to receive roughly 1,800 liters of subsidized petrol annually, allowing it to run about 60 km per day, suitable for average daily consumption for cars in Egypt.

Trucks owners, on the other hand, are scheduled to get 10,000 liters of diesel and petrol per year, and according to their license type could also obtain additional quantities at cost from the local market.

When asked about exactly when the subsidy restructuring would be implemented, Kamal said he could not give an exact date, as this was a decision beyond the control of his ministry.

He added that these plans were not linked to the upcoming parliamentary elections, or the upcoming constitutional referendum, as has been rumored.

Analysts say the restructuring of the energy subsidies is imperative for the government to obtain loans from the International Monetary Fund and other international financing institutions, to help bridge the budget deficit.

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , ,

 

Egypt's government plans to cut energy subsidies by setting a universal limit on how much cheap fuel and cooking gas every household can buy, Petroleum Minister Osama Kamal told a newspaper on Sunday.

An Islamist-led administration that took office in July has vowed to push through reform of the subsidies, which consume as much as a quarter of the state budget, to lower an unmanageable deficit and shift funds to health and education.

Economists say the IMF will not release a US$4.8 billion loan until Egypt shows how it will cut a deficit that ballooned after a popular uprising tipped the economy into crisis last year.

The government has committed itself to subsidy reform without saying precisely how or when it will happen.

The plan outlined by Kamal in an interview with newspaper Al-Shurouk would mean both rich and poor receive the same allocation of the subsidized fuel and would then pay a higher price for additional amounts consumed.

The government "is committed to subsidizing petrol for only one car per family", the paper quoted Kamal as saying.

Each car with a maximum 1.6 liter engine would be allocated around 1,800 liters of subsidized fuel a year, enough to travel 60 kilometer per day, he said, a "suitable estimate for average daily consumption of private cars in Egypt".

He was referring to 80-, 90- and 92-grade gasoline, while prices of higher-grade 95 gasoline would be raised to what the government pays for it.

Unspecified amounts of subsidized diesel, known as solar in Egypt, would be issued for trucks, three-wheeler passenger vehicles, mini-buses and buses for transporting children to schools whose fees are regulated by the state, he said.

Each Egyptian family would receive 1.5 to 2 cylinders of fully subsidized butane cooking gas per month and further consumption would be partially subsidized, Kamal said.

"The government can't move prices in one go so as to avoid raising average inflation significantly," he said. "All citizens will be treated equally, so whoever has a luxury villa will be treated equally to the rest in receiving butane gas cylinders."

He did not give a deadline for the start of subsidy rationing or specify what would constitute a family for the purposes of the plan. Another minister said last week that coupons for subsidized butane would be issued towards year-end.

A growing population and high global prices pushed Egypt's petroleum product subsidy bill to 28 billion Egyptian pounds ($4.59 billion) in the July-September quarter, up from 18 billion in the same period a year earlier, according to Kamal.

He said the scale of subsidy cuts planned for in the government's 2012/13 fiscal year budget would not be realized "because it was put on the basis that the restructuring would begin from early July and this has not happened".

Tags: ,

The deputy governor of the Central Bank of Egypt has called for the restructuring of energy subsidies, which are a LE100 million annual burden on the state budget.

In a meeting with the Shura Council’s economic and financial committee on Monday, Governor Nedal al-Qassem said restoring security would attract foreign investments and hence provide essential resources to plug the budget deficit.

The Cabinet also demanded that Parliament clarify its stance on reducing petroleum subsidies in the 2012-13 state budget, Al-Masry Al-Youm has learned. Should the subsidies remain as is, the budget is expected to exceed LE130 billion. The final decision will be left to the next president.

A source at the Petroleum Ministry close to the issue said there are several choices for its resolution. He said the current subsidy policy could be reduced, or a coupon-system of distributing goods could be introduced.

Petroleum Minister Abdullah Ghorab said the Cabinet discussed different methods of reducing the subsidy allotment last week, seeking to find a new arrangement that could increase funding for education, health and social justice.

Ghorab added that the head of the General Petroleum Authority had submitted two proposals to the Cabinet on methods of reducing subsidies. He said Parliament and the new president would have the final say on the issue.

General Petroleum Authority head Hany Dahy said detailed surveys have been conducted over how to reduce subsidies by 50 percent in three years. However, he said, this would require a public referendum before being approved.

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , , , ,

The government aims to achieve a growth rate of between 4 and 4.5 percent during the 2012/2013 fiscal year, said Minister of Planning and International Cooperation Fayza Abouelnaga on Monday.

In a press statement, Abouelnaga said this was a “bold” goal under the current circumstances. She explained that the government aims to create greater investment opportunities and correct the problem of energy subsidies without compromising subsidies of basic goods.

Abouelnaga said that Prime Minister Kamal al-Ganzouri on Monday discussed the final draft of the budget for the 2012/2013 fiscal year, the first year of the first post-revolution five-year plan, and that it would be presented to the Cabinet on Wednesday.

She went on to say that the budget reflects social justice as there is a specific economic and social development plan.

Meanwhile, in a press statement, Finance Minister Momtaz al-Saeed said draft budget expenditures amounted to LE537.7 billion as compared to LE476 billion before the recent amendment to the current budget.

Revenues amounted to LE392.4 billion as compared to LE349.6 billion during the current fiscal year. The gap in the next budget amounts to LE145.3 billion.

State employees' wages rose to LE138.6 billion from LE117.5 billion in order to accommodate 25 percent of the state’s expenses that take into account periodic raises and incentives.

Saeed went on to say that the draft subsidies were cut to LE112.5 billion from LE132.9 billion, and that LE26.6 billion had been allocated for subsidized goods, including the LE16.6 billion for wheat and corn procurement.

He added that subsidized petroleum products were estimated at LE70 billion, down from LE95.5 billion in the current budget.

He explained that the reduction will be achieved by rationing subsidies without affecting gas subsidies for low-income citizens.

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm
 

Tags: , ,

The government is planning the total abolition of subsidies for petroleum products by 2018, with official sources saying gasoline and diesel would be distributed using coupons over five years, and prices of 95 octane gasoline would be raised gradually.

Speaking on condition of anonymity, the sources said the government is holding intensive meetings this month to discuss the plan submitted by the General Petroleum Authority to lower the budget deficit by reducing energy subsidies from LE111 billion to LE108.9 billion this fiscal year.

“The ordinary citizen does not benefit from the current subsidy system,” said Hany Dahy, head of the authority.

Edited translation from Al-Masry Al-Youm

Tags: , ,

 

Egypt's interim government will have to muster all its skills of persuasion to sell austerity measures to a country weary after a year of political and economic strife, if details emerging on Cairo's planned deal with the IMF are anything to go by.

Egypt wants the US$3.2 billion IMF accord to help it head off a looming crisis. But in return the IMF wants Egypt to cut its budget deficit.

"The IMF agreement has conditions that Egypt is expected to fulfill for the money to come," said an Egyptian official who has been closely following the talks. "One of them is reducing the country's budget deficit."

The official, who asked not to be named because he is not authorised to speak to the media, added that "those conditions have political consequences" and this is why officials have said in the past that IMF conditions affect Egypt's sovereignty.

The IMF has asked Egypt to draw up an economic reform plan with benchmarks and targets, sell the plan to the country's political forces, and line up aid pledges from other donors.

The unelected administration will be proposing the related measures as it steers the country through the contentious process of drafting a new constitution and holding a presidential election by the end of June.

The government announced this month it had approved a plan that would run for the length of the 18-month IMF program and would sign an accord in March. But so far it has not released the plan for public debate as promised, and the IMF has said tersely that talks are still underway.

Few details have been released on the plan's austerity measures, but on 10 February Finance Minister Momtaz al-Saeed was quoted as saying it includes changing Egypt's 10 percent sales tax to a value-added tax (VAT) and directing energy subsidies to those who most need it.

New taxes and fewer subsidies are never popular, and the government has long tried unsuccessfully to enact similar measures. The sales tax was introduced as part of an earlier IMF programme in 1991 as the first step toward a VAT, and Youssef Boutros-Ghali, finance minister under Mubarak, had argued for a switchover to VAT throughout his seven years in office.

The now-reviled Boutros-Ghali also tried to tackle energy subsidies, which are eating up an ever-increasing share of the state budget as consumption grows.

As recently as late 2010 he sought a rationing system for subsidised liquid petroleum gas (LPG) sold in canisters for household cooking. Energy subsidies, especially for diesel, LPG and fuel for industry, make up almost 20 percent of the budget.

 

Time bomb?

The Egyptian uprising was driven in part by economic grievances, and a year later strikes by workers demanding higher pay and better contracts continue to break out daily.

"How will you reduce subsidies when people are complaining about inflation, unemployment and inequality? It will be a hot potato in terms of the politics," said Raza Agha, an economist at the Royal Bank of Scotland.

The IMF has demanded that any accord have broad political support within Egypt, especially from the Muslim Brotherhood, which won nearly half the seats in the new parliament. The Brotherhood so far has rejected an accord except as a last resort, but analysts say it may have no choice but to go along.

A big question is whether Egypt has the resources to get through the presidential vote before a financial crisis hits.

The country has been spending $2 billion a month of its foreign reserves since October to prop up its currency. Reserves, less than half of what they were before the uprising, now stand at a worryingly low $16 billion, including $4 billion in gold bullion the government would be loath to draw down.

"If they carry on at the current rate, their reserves would nearly all be exhausted by then," said Said Hirsh of Capital Economics. "Then they would be at tipping point, which means you could get a totally disorderly devaluation."

This would boost inflation, prompt the government to raise interest rates to support the currency, reduce asset values and push borrowing costs up in an already weak economy, he added.

Even if it gets internal backing for the plan, the IMF has said Egypt must line up funds from foreign lenders to plug a funding gap the government estimates at $11 billion over the 18-month program, meaning it would still have find about $8 billion from donors other than the IMF.

Egypt has asked the World Bank for $1 billion, the European Union for $660 million and $500 million each from the African Development Bank and the Arab Monetary Fund.

The country seems to be counting on help from Gulf states for the rest, but the finance minister was quoted last week as saying the fate of that aid was unclear. Saudi Arabia had pledged last year to provide up to $3 billion in budget support.

Prime Minister Kamal al-Ganzouri has said Gulf countries wanted an IMF agreement before they lend money to Egypt. Analysts say they also may not be comfortable sending funds until they see what kind of government emerges in July.

As a backup, Egypt is studying other ways to fund its budget shortfall, including selling certificates of deposits and land to Egyptians living abroad and issuing Islamic sukuk bonds.

The danger is that many of these are one-off measures that don't reduce the budget deficit in the long term, analysts say.

Tags: , , , ,